Free shipping on all US orders of $20 or more.

You have no products

Add your favorite cosmetic, choose an additional care product or test something completely new. One thing is certain - your skin will thank you for it. See similar entries.

Shop now

Synthetic Soap VS Natural Soap: The Real Truth

Synthetic Soap VS Natural Soap: The Real Truth

Hey there, curious soul!

Ever wondered if making the switch from synthetic to natural soaps is truly worth it?

Well, you're not alone in pondering this increasingly searched question.

Welcome to the candid conversation on Natural Soap vs. Synthetic Soap – where we're getting real about the nitty-gritty details.

Are you ready to explore the sudsy world of soap, from its bacterial battles to its environmental impact?

Let's dive right in!?

Natural Soap VS Synthetic Soap:

  1. What Is The Difference?
  2. Do They Kill Bacteria?
  3. Are They Kind To Your Skin?
  4. Are They Kind to The Environment?
  5. Are They Affordable?
  6. What Ingredients to Look Out For?
  7. Are They Sustainable?
  8. Testimonials from Natural Soap Converts
  9. A Biochemist’s Insights
  10. Myth Busting
  11. Exploring Soaps Traditions Around the World
  12. Learn More

Soap – once just a mundane part of our daily routine – now takes center stage in our quest for healthier choices.

But before we can do better, we need to know better.

So, let's unravel the truth together, armed with knowledge and a passion for cleaner, greener living.

1. What’s The Key Difference Between Synthetic and Natural Soap?

When I stroll down the soap aisle at my local supermarket, it's hard to miss the overwhelming array of synthetic options lining the shelves.

Despite the buzz around alternative products, many people still gravitate towards these commercial soaps.

But here's the thing – they're often loaded with artificial additives and harsh chemicals like parabens and sulfates, which can be pretty tough on our skin.

Now, let's talk natural soap.

natural soap

 

It's a whole different ball game!

Crafted from plant-based oils, essential oils, and botanical ingredients, it's like a breath of fresh air for our skin.

No synthetic fragrances or harsh detergents here!

And the best part?

Natural soap holds onto glycerin, a moisturizing gem that's naturally produced during the soap-making process, leaving our skin feeling oh-so-hydrated and happy.

At the end of the day, it's all about the ingredients and how they're crafted – and natural soap?

Well, it's all about purity, sustainability, and giving our skin the love it deserves.

Back to top

2. Do Synthetic Soap and Natural Soap Kill Bacteria?

So, synthetic soap?

Yeah, it's got those antibacterial agents like triclosan or triclocarban, aimed at wiping out bacteria.

But here's the catch – there's this growing concern about using too much of these antibacterial ingredients and how they might not be so great for our health or the environment.

We'll get into that a little more later.

Oh, and by the way, not all bacteria are bad guys!

Some are actually essential for keeping our skin in tip-top shape.

Does Natural Soap Kill Bacteria?

Yep, it takes care of bacteria too, but not all of them!

Natural soaps are cleverly crafted with ingredients like tea tree oil or lavender oil, which have these amazing antimicrobial powers.

Natural Soap Bacteria

 

And even though they might not pack the same punch as synthetic soaps, when you team them up with a good scrub and rinse, they do a stellar job of cleansing your skin while keeping that delicate balance intact.

It's like a gentle hug for your skin, you know?

But hey, if you're dealing with something serious and need to wipe out every last germ, then reaching for a natural sanitizer might be the way to go.

Back to top

3. Is Soap Good For Your Skin?

Let's talk about synthetic soap first.

You see, how it affects your skin really depends on what's inside.

A lot of synthetic soaps pack in harsh stuff like parabens, sulfates, and artificial fragrances.

These can be real troublemakers, stripping your skin of its natural oils and leaving you with dryness, irritation, and sometimes even allergies.

Plus, they mess with your skin's pH balance, which can lead to issues like eczema, dermatitis, and acne.

Over time, using these harsh soaps can make your skin chronically dry, speed up aging, and make you more vulnerable to environmental nasties.

But hey, not all synthetic soaps are made the same way. Some are designed to be gentler, especially for sensitive skin.

You'll usually find them labeled as hypoallergenic or dermatologist-tested.

Still, it's crucial to check the ingredient list carefully and pick products that match what your skin needs.

Is Natural Soap Good for Your Skin?

First off, it's made from gentle ingredients like olive oil, coconut oil, or shea butter.

These goodies are packed with stuff like vitamins, antioxidants, and fatty acids that really give your skin a boost.

And the best part?

They're way less likely to cause any irritation or allergic reactions compared to those synthetic chemicals in commercial soaps.

Then there's the fact that natural soaps steer clear of harsh chemicals like detergents, fragrances, and preservatives.

Natural Soaps

 

Instead, they use botanical ingredients and essential oils to give you that lovely scent and all those therapeutic benefits.

So, say goodbye to dryness, itching, and inflammation caused by the chemicals in regular soap.

Another cool thing about natural soap is that it holds onto glycerin, a natural moisturizer that forms during the soap-making process.

Unlike commercial soaps that often remove glycerin and sell it separately, natural soap keeps it right where it belongs – on your skin, keeping it hydrated and soft.

And let's not forget about the pH balance.

Natural soaps usually have a pH that's similar to your skin's natural pH, which means they help maintain its protective barrier and reduce the risk of irritation and sensitivity.

This is especially great news if you've got sensitive or delicate skin.

Oh, and here's a tip – go for natural soaps with organic ingredients for the best results.

They're like a spa day for your skin, giving you a gentle cleanse that's truly kind and nurturing.

Back to top

4. Is Soap Kind To The Environment?

On the whole synthetic soaps aren’t doing us or the planet any favors.

Here's why:

First off, there's the environmental pollution.

Many synthetic soaps are loaded with harsh chemicals like parabens, sulfates, and artificial fragrances.

When these chemicals wash down the drain, they end up in our waterways, harming aquatic life and disrupting delicate ecosystems.

Then there's the packaging waste.

Synthetic soaps often come wrapped in single-use plastic or excessive packaging, adding to the plastic pollution crisis and filling up landfills.

sustainable natural soaps

 

The whole process – from production to disposal – takes a toll on the environment, releasing greenhouse gases and depleting precious resources.

And let's not forget about the health concerns.

The chemicals in synthetic soaps, like parabens and sulfates, have been linked to all sorts of issues, from skin irritation to allergic reactions and even endocrine disruption.

Not exactly what you want to be lathering up with, right?

Oh, and did I mention microplastics?

Some synthetic soaps contain these tiny plastic particles that wreak havoc on marine life and can even end up in our food chain, posing health risks to us humans.

Are Natural Soaps Kind to The Environment? 

First off, they're made with gentle ingredients like plant-based oils, botanical extracts, and essential oils, packed with vitamins, antioxidants, and fatty acids that nourish and moisturize your skin without causing irritation.

Plus, they're biodegradable, meaning they break down naturally over time without leaving behind any nasty residues or polluting our environment.

That's a win-win for Mother Nature and our aquatic friends.

And the sourcing?

Many (not all) natural soap companies are all about sustainability, using organic ingredients and supporting fair trade initiatives.

It's important to do your homework so you can feel good about where your soap comes from.

Minimal packaging is also a big plus – think recycled paper or cardboard instead of plastic.

natural soaps VS synthetic soaps

 

Some brands even offer package-free options or refill programs to cut down on waste even more.

But here's the best part – natural soaps are great for your skin.

They help maintain its natural balance and hydration, reducing the risk of dryness, irritation, and allergic reactions.

And since they avoid all those synthetic chemicals, you're cutting down on your exposure to potential health risks in the long run.

So, making the switch to natural soap isn't just about pampering your skin – it's about taking a small but impactful step towards a healthier, more planet-friendly lifestyle.

Back to top

5. Synthetic VS Natural Soap - Is It Affordable?

So, synthetic soaps are everywhere, right?

And it's no wonder – they're super cheap and easy to find.

But here's the thing: that low price?

It comes with a catch.

As noted in this blog, there's more to it than meets the eye.

Is Natural Soap Expensive?

It tends to be a bit pricier than synthetic soap.

But trust me, it's worth it.

See, there's a reason for that higher price tag.

It's all about the quality – the ingredients, the production process, and yeah, even the ethics behind it all.

Sure, it might seem like a splurge at first, but think about what you're getting in return. 

natural soap bundle cheap

 

Natural soap isn't just about cleaning your skin – it's about nourishing it, protecting it, and yeah, even pampering it a little.

So, next time you're debating between synthetic and natural, remember: sometimes, paying a little extra, if you can afford it, is worth it in the long run.

Back to top

6. What Ingredients to Look Out for In Soap?

Let's talk about some ingredients to watch out for in synthetic soaps:

  • Parabens: These are preservatives that can mess with your hormones and cause skin issues. Sulfates (SLS/SLES): These are what make your soap lather up, but they can also dry out your skin and cause irritation.
  • Artificial Fragrances: They might smell nice, but they often contain phthalates, which can mess with your hormones and cause allergies.
  • Triclosan: This antibacterial agent can mess with your hormones and harm the environment.
  • Formaldehyde: It's a known carcinogen and can cause skin irritation. Look out for Formaldehyde releasers too. These ingredients can release formaldehyde over time, so avoid products listing them to minimize exposure.
  • Propylene Glycol: It can irritate your skin, especially if you're sensitive.
  • PEG Compounds: They can be contaminated with carcinogens and cause skin irritation. When you're shopping for synthetic soaps, keep an eye on the ingredient list and avoid products with these harmful substances.

But how do they show up on labels? 

I've created this infograph to help you remember. 

Why not save it to your phone for easy access at anytime? 

How to spot harmful ingredients on self care products

 

 

Now, let's switch gears and talk about some amazing ingredients to keep an eye out for in natural soaps.

Highly Beneficial Natural Soap Ingredients: 

  • Charcoal: Great for detoxifying and deep cleansing.
  • Rosehip: Moisturizes, brightens, and rejuvenates the skin.
  • Pink Clay: Draws out impurities while promoting a healthy complexion.
  • Turmeric: Calms inflammation, reduces acne, and brightens the skin.
  • Madder Root: Natural colorant with antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties.
  • Wheatgrass: Packed with nutrients that nourish and rejuvenate the skin. These ingredients work wonders for your skin, leaving it healthy, radiant, and refreshed.

Back to top

7. Are Synthetic and Natural Soaps Sustainable?

Synthetic soaps aren't usually sustainable due to a few key reasons:

  • Production: They're often made using non-renewable resources like fossil fuels, which contribute to carbon emissions.
  • Chemical Pollution: Harsh chemicals in synthetic soaps can harm aquatic life and pollute waterways.
  • Packaging Waste: Many come in single-use plastic, adding to plastic pollution and landfill waste.
  • Health Concerns: Chemicals like parabens and sulfates can cause skin irritation and other health issues. There might be exceptions, so it's wise to research before buying.
synthetic soap sulfates

Are Natural Soaps Sustainable?

Now, let's talk about why natural soaps can be a more sustainable choice:

  • Renewable Ingredients: They're often made from plant-based oils and extracts that can be sustainably sourced.
  • Biodegradability: Natural soap ingredients break down over time without harming the environment.
  • Minimal Packaging: Many come in eco-friendly packaging, reducing plastic waste.
  • Ethical Sourcing: Manufacturers often prioritize fair trade and support local communities.
  • Environmental Stewardship: They usually involve fewer synthetic chemicals, lowering pollution. While they're not perfect, choosing natural soaps can be a step towards a more eco-conscious lifestyle.

Back to top

8. Testimonials From Customers Who Made The Switch

I love the all natural ingredients, eco friendly packaging, and the fact its a black owned business! The shipping was fast and as someone with sensitive skin this perfect. I use it on my body not face only because any soap on my face dries it out, but as a body wash it is so hydrating. Before I even put lotion on my skin felt soft. And as someone with sensitivity to smell I liked that it didn’t have any aggressive smell to it. It has more that freshly clean smell. (Note: bar is a nice size, not to small or big 👍 )

Read more reviews. 

Shop our products: 

Back to top

9. A Biochemist’s Insights

A note from our founder: 

Hey there! If you got this far it’s time I introduced myself properly.

I'm Monique Kofsky, the Founder of Butter & Lye, a Natural Soap Company.

My journey into soapmaking was sparked by a blend of passion for skincare and a background in biochemistry.

Understanding the nitty-gritty of chemical properties got me hooked (I used to teach science too).

Monique Kofsky

I take pride in handpicking organic ingredients, ensuring they not only deliver specific skincare benefits but also play nice together in my soap recipes.

It's all about crafting gentle yet effective soaps that put your skin's health and safety first.

Quality is non-negotiable for me.

That's why I'm all about rigorous quality control, making sure our raw materials and finished products meet the highest standards.

I'm constantly on the lookout for new ways to innovate.

Researching and refining my formulations is my jam, to create top-notch, eco-friendly natural soap products that'll treat your skin right and leave a positive impact on the planet.

Back to top

10. Myth Busting

At Butter & Lye we're passionate about spreading knowledge, so while we are here, let's tackle some common myths about natural soaps:

Myth: Natural soaps don't clean as well as synthetic ones.

Reality: Actually, natural soaps can clean effectively without harsh chemicals. Ingredients like plant-based oils and botanicals have natural cleansing properties that remove dirt while keeping your skin nourished.

Myth: Natural soaps can't kill bacteria effectively.

Reality: Many natural ingredients, like tea tree oil and lavender oil, have antibacterial properties, making natural soaps great at killing bacteria. Plus, the act of washing with soap and water helps remove bacteria from your skin's surface.

Myth: Natural soaps aren't suitable for sensitive skin.

Reality: Natural soaps are often gentler, making them perfect for sensitive skin. Ingredients like olive oil and shea butter can soothe and moisturize without causing irritation.

Myth: Natural soaps are pricey and hard to find.

Reality: While some artisanal options might be pricier, there are plenty of affordable natural soaps out there. Some brands even offer budget-friendly options without sacrificing quality.

Myth: Natural soaps don't lather well.

Reality: Natural soaps can create a rich lather, just like synthetic ones. Ingredients like coconut oil contribute to lather formation, giving you a luxurious cleansing experience.

natural soap lather

 

By busting these myths, I hope to show you that natural soaps are not only effective but also gentle, nourishing, and eco-friendly alternatives to synthetic options.

Back to top

11. Exploring Soapmaking Traditions Around the World

As many of us return to, and value the homespun, I believe it's essential to honor and appreciate the multitude of soapmaking traditions from different cultures worldwide.

These traditions hold significant cultural value and offer a diverse perspective on this timeless craft.

By embracing collaboration and sharing knowledge, we can blend traditional practices with modern innovation and sustainability efforts, paving the way for a cleaner, brighter future.

Cultural Diversity

Soapmaking techniques vary greatly across cultures, with each region showcasing its distinct methods and preferences.

soap making around the world

 

From Syria's ancient Aleppo soap to Spain's luxurious Castile soap, cultural heritage profoundly influences soapmaking traditions globally.

Regional Ingredients

Different regions utilize their natural resources to create unique soap formulations.

For instance, African black soap incorporates shea butter (pssst. I'm african-american so you'll find shea in all my soaps) and plantain skins, while Japanese soaps feature rice bran oil and seaweed extracts, showcasing the diversity of ingredients used worldwide.

Production Techniques

Traditional soapmaking methods are passed down through generations, preserving ancestral knowledge and artisanal skills. Whether it's cold-process, hot-process, or other techniques, each method imparts its own characteristics to the final product, resulting in a wide range of textures, fragrances, and properties.

Back to top

12. Learn More: Discover Other Blogs You May Find Interesting

  1. Parabens & Sulfates | Why Avoid Them? 
  2. Discover The Best Natural Soap for Your Skin Type or Concern
  3. Are Shampoo Bars Good For Curly Hair? 

Thank you for reading!

Have you recently made the switch from synthetic soap to natural soap?

What was your reason?

How are you finding it?

We would love to hear more about your experience in the comments. 

Join our sensitive skin community on Instagram: 

 

Back to top

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!